Discussion in 'General Education' started by Ms.Holyoke, Mar 8, 2019.
Mar 13, 2019
I'm surprised you would need behavioral incentives like that in a private school...
I think that the kids are better behaved for them. Most of the teachers in my school are great and hard working.
This is correct. I teach in a very affluent suburban school and even in that environment there are many behavior issues that I know won't be addressed. So I pick my battles. I'm in my 14th year...and the issues have lessened in some ways. In general, however, I notice that more and more, the "inmates run the asylum," so to speak. I think it's partly a culture shift, unfortunately.
*English teachers: am I using too many commas??
NOOOOOOOOO a student shouldn't be rewarded for what is essentially "expected" behavior! I totally get why you would do this, but I was really uncomfortable reading that!
Once per quarter is not too pricey and I only spend ~$250/year and I only give out 5 awards across all of my periods.
Basically, I give gift cards to the following 5 students: 1) the student who most improves behavior wise, 2) the student who doesn’t talk out of turn and doesn’t interrupt, 3) the student who actively encourages others, 4) the student who is most polite to myself and others, and 5) the student who volunteers and helps others to succeed.
I don’t let my students know my metric for selecting who wins and I try to switch it up so it’s not always the same 5 students who win each quarter, though a few sometimes do win more than once.
Kids of all backgrounds misbehave. It’s not specific to any social class. And my high school is 60% middle class/upper class (mostly middle) and 40% working class, on average.
Sure, but I do it because I want to. It also helps some of the problem students because they have something to look forward to, at least.
It made you really uncomfortable? Really?
Mar 17, 2019 at 7:05 PM
I went to the interview of the school in the same district that I student taught in. The school seemed fine but the job is for THREE grade levels (6th, 7th, and 8th). I received a demo for this week but I think I'll turn it down...I do not want to plan for 3 grade levels!!
Mar 17, 2019 at 7:06 PM
It is just really surprising that you would need these types of behavioral incentives. I haven't heard of anything like it + it would be frowned upon in my school.
In my experience, low-income schools generally have more behavioral issues as do "lower" students. In my school, behavior is excellent in the pre-AP and honors classes and behavior is more challenging in the college level and inclusion classes.
Mar 17, 2019 at 10:51 PM
To be fair, I never said I *need* these behavioral incentives. I do it because I like rewarding certain students for doing the right thing even when they are not asked to. Also, I think it is important to reward and recognize students other than just those who have the highest grades. This is one way of doing that. Plus, I think it’s only fair because I get cash gifts and gift cards from students all the time.
And, no offense, but I would not be too concerned if a practice I did were frowned upon in my school so long as it was moral and legal. I think it’s equally valid that you don’t do this, but that doesn’t mean I shouldn’t because you or others don’t.
Mar 18, 2019 at 4:23 AM
Sometimes it’s nice to get some acknowledgement even if you are doing what is ‘expected’. It applies to adults and students. We thank our parents on Mother’s Day or Father’s Day or Parent Day for being good parents, and buy them gifts or a meal, even though it is an expectation that our parents should be good parents. Our students buy us gifts to thank us for being good teachers and mentors, even though we get paid to do so and they expect it from us. It feels nice and appreciated to get that acknowledgement. So personally, I don’t see a problem with rewarding students with something that they want, for doing something that is expected, lesson after lesson, day after day, month after month. As long as it’s above board and transparent.
Mar 18, 2019 at 5:35 AM
Mar 18, 2019 at 9:33 AM
At the first nanosecond of reading about the gift cards, I was stunned.
Then again, I grew up with teachers doing similar things on occasion and I know plenty of teachers who love prize boxes (which I actually imagine paying for adds up to at least if not more of what @futuremathsprof is spending on gift cards).
It doesn't fit my philosophy, but they're not pricey gift cards nor does it sound like an everyday thing.
Do your thing.
Mar 18, 2019 at 9:58 AM
Thanks for your understanding and support.
Separate names with a comma.